A National GASP at SNL’s “Sister” Sketch

SNL’s fake commercial advertises “Sister” a FREE 24/7 caregiver. She manages medications, doctors, insurance calls, meals, cleaning and bathroom help. She may even quit her job, leave her home and move across the country.

The visceral "gasp" to this sketch is seen EVERYWHERE this week. We think it is because for so many families, it hits far too close to home.

Depicted in this 3 minutes sketch, is what plays out in many American households every day. The women, the daughters, are taking on the brunt of caregiving for their parents like programmed robots, sacrificing much more than what anyone wants to talk about.

Though advertised here as free caregiving…Caregiving always comes with a cost.

Someone Always Pays

Every time a family caregiver “helps out” they pay with their time, income, sleep, relationships (spouses, children, and community) and most significantly with their own health.

Family caregivers can find themselves:

· Missing work or reducing their hours

· Managing medications and medical appointments

· Helping with bathing, dressing and toileting

· Paying expenses from their own pockets

· Neglecting spouses, children or their own retirement

· Making major care decisions while exhausted

Why does it land on the daughters?

No one decides it. It just seems to happen, because within many families and society at large, it is believed that women are not only the best caregivers but it is their responsibility. The rationale looks like: The daughter lives closest. She is "good at this." She likes taking care of Mom and Dad. She’d worry if she isn't right there.

With these societal rules in place, few family members step in to ask her if she needs help OR if they can take a turn.

The numbers back it up. Three in five family caregivers are women, and nearly 1 in 4 give 40 or more hours of care a week. One often-cited study found daughters give about twice the care sons do.

Money makes it harder. Paid help costs about $35 an hour, or roughly $80,000 a year at 44 hours a week. Medicare generally does not pay for long-term custodial care. So, families default to Sister.

Let’s look at the real cost of the sacrifice:

  • Her paycheck goes away as she steps away from work
  • Her retirement savings stalls or decreases with new expenses
  • Her health and sleep are consumed by expectations
  • Her marriage and friendships – Relationships faulter without attention
  • Her bond with her siblings is tense or adversarial as overwhelm and/or resentment sets in

It Does Not Have to Be This Way

A text saying “Dad fell” should not be the first family meeting about elder care.

A crisis, overwhelm, and hard feelings are not where this discussion should start.

The discussion should start while parents can still clearly express what they want, how they want to live, what they want their “quality of life” to look like at every stage.

Starting early gives families the opportunity to discuss questions such as: Where do Mom and Dad want to live if they needs help? Who can realistically provide care – us or outside help? What happens if primary caregiver needs a break? How can we support family caregivers? Who can make financial and health decisions? How will care be paid for?

When the whole family understands what is coming, what is at stake, what resource are and are not available, and what it takes to care for aging parents, caring for mom and dad is less of a burden and more about helping everyone live their best life through this season.

Siblings do not have to contribute in identical ways for this to work. These discussions are about creating complimentary and supportive ways to actively support both mom and dad, and each other.

The goal is not perfect equality. The goal here is to create a known, actionable, well resourced, and intentional plan.

Elder Law Turns a Family Problem Into a Family Plan

This is where elder law planning goes beyond having a will or trust.

A caring elder law attorney leads a collaborative conversation by helping each family member understand at the whole aging journey: housing options, care giving responsibilities, legal authority, powers of attorney, health care documents, long-term care costs, asset preservation, insurance and pre-Medicaid planning (important for estate values up to $5M).

Elder law planning allows the aging parents and their adult children to preserve more choices and create a better quality of life for everyone. Waiting for a hospitalization, dementia diagnosis or caregiver breakdown can narrow these options.

“Sister” is kind of funny because there is truth beneath the joke. The lesson here is: One person shouldn’t be expected to carry the whole load. Your family can walk this season differently.

Talk early. Share the load. Put the plan in writing.

Our elder law attorney will lead you through the discussion and help all of you create a plan that directs and supports those decisions.

Attend our next Legacy Care Event through the Silvas Law Events page, or schedule a personalized appointment with our office to begin your family's elder law conversation before a crisis makes those decisions for you.

Silvas Law 817-264-7447

Serving Grapevine, Alliance, Ft Worth, Dallas

A National GASP at SNL’s “Sister” Sketch

FAQs – Blog Shortcut

Why do daughters usually become the main caregiver for aging parents? Daughters often become the main caregiver because of proximity and social expectation, not a family decision. Three in five family caregivers are women, and nearly 1 in 4 give 40 or more hours of care a week. Without an early family plan, the role falls to whoever lives closest.

Does Medicare pay for long-term care for an aging parent? No, Medicare generally does not pay for long-term custodial care, such as help with bathing, dressing, or toileting. Paid help costs about $35 an hour, or roughly $80,000 a year at 44 hours a week. Families often cover this through savings, long-term care insurance, or Medicaid planning.

How can families share elder care instead of leaving it to one person? Start the conversation before a crisis, while parents can say what they want. Decide who can provide care, who can make financial and health decisions, and how care will be paid for. An elder law attorney from Silvas Law can lead that discussion and put the plan in writing.